Is Eugenol Compliant? Limits by Product Type
"Is eugenol compliant?" sounds like a yes-or-no question, but the same drop of eugenol is treated differently depending on what you put it in. Under the IFRA Standard a candle, a bar of soap, a perfume and a reed diffuser sit in four different categories, and the limits across the Standard run from 0.14% to 18% of the finished product, with one category carrying no limit at all. Here is how to sort out which rule belongs to which product.
Restricted, not banned
The IFRA Standard on eugenol (CAS 97-53-0) is classed as a Restriction, and it names the drivers as dermal sensitization and systemic toxicity (IFRA Standards, 51st Amendment, pp. 103-105). Sensitisation means a person can become allergic, after which much smaller exposures can set off a reaction. That is why we describe eugenol as a recognised skin sensitiser, and why we tell buyers to keep it off undiluted skin, wash hands after handling, keep it away from eyes, children and pets, and never use it internally. We make no medical claims for it and do not offer it for dental or therapeutic use.
Three layers that get mixed up
The law. Cosmetic regulation, such as the EU and UK allergen labelling rules, decides what must appear on a label. Eugenol is among the fragrance allergens that must be declared on cosmetic labels in the EU and UK above set thresholds. Our allergen labelling article walks through the detail.
Industry code. IFRA's Standards are the yardstick your fragrance supplier writes certificates against. IFRA's own Guidance says that observing them is necessary for compliance with the IFRA Code of Practice but "may not be sufficient to ensure regulatory compliance" (IFRA Guidance, 51st Amendment). In plain terms, "IFRA compliant" and "legal" are not synonyms. The category-by-category numbers are in our IFRA explainer.
Hazard communication. This is the safety data sheet and the GHS label. PubChem's roundup of company notifications to ECHA for eugenol (2,820 reports) shows "may cause an allergic skin reaction" in 99.8% and eye irritation in 80.4% (PubChem, eugenol). Those are notifications rather than an official classification, so the SDS from your own supplier is the document that governs. OSHA's SDS brief explains the sixteen sections and notes that suppliers must provide an SDS to downstream users (OSHA, Hazard Communication Standard: Safety Data Sheets); our SDS reading guide shows which sections matter.
The categories that matter most
IFRA places each product type in a category, and the eugenol limit applies to the finished product, not to your neat oil or your concentrate. Here are a few common ones from the 51st Amendment.
| Product | IFRA category | Eugenol limit in the finished product |
|---|---|---|
| Candles of all types | 12 | No restriction |
| Bar soap | 9 | 4.9% |
| Fine fragrance | 4 | 2.5% |
| Body lotion and body oil | 5A | 0.64% |
| Lip products | 1 | 0.45% |
| Underarm products | 2 | 0.14% |
| Reed diffusers | 10A | 4.0% |
Two details trip people up. IFRA puts reed diffusers in Category 10A on purpose, because the soaked reeds are handled by hand, and the Guidance says a review of Categories 10, 11 and 12 was foreseen for a later amendment, so check the current one. And the Guidance says indirect contributions count: eugenol carried in by clove leaf or cinnamon leaf oil is added to your total, and an analysed level beats an indicative one. Our worked example shows how to do that sum.
What number to start from for skin
For anything that stays on skin, we would start from the low end of the range: our guidance puts the ceiling for leave-on products at around half a percent, and the category table shows why. Body creams and oils are capped at 0.64%, lip products at 0.45% and underarm products at 0.14%. A figure in a general dilution chart is never a substitute for the category row that matches your product, so read that row first, then patch test.
Don't forget methyl eugenol
Methyl eugenol is a separate restricted material with limits far tighter than eugenol's (0.011% in fine fragrance and 0.0017% in bar soap, from the same Standards). To do that arithmetic you need an analysis that reports it, and our post on eugenol and methyl eugenol explains what to ask for. The same goes for any document you need beyond the Certificate of Analysis we publish for one batch (density, refractive index, appearance and smell): ask us in writing through our contact page, and ask for the SDS and IFRA certificate from any supplier whose material you use.
A simple habit: one page per product
The easiest way to keep this under control is to keep one page per product. At the top, write the product and its category. Underneath, list every ingredient that carries eugenol and how much, then the limit that applies. When you reformulate, you update the page. When someone asks you a question next year, you already have the answer. It is not glamorous, but it is the thing that quietly protects a small business.
Who to ask
A regulatory specialist or cosmetic attorney decides what applies to your product and market. A cosmetic chemist or toxicologist handles the exposure sums when a formula has several eugenol sources. For a child or pet exposed to a candle, diffuser or spill, call a physician, poison control or a veterinarian; our pets post covers what makers should warn about.
The category, the dilution and the paperwork are yours to work out for each product, and the sources below are a good place to begin.
Sources & Further Reading
- IFRA Standards, 51st Amendment (eugenol, pp. 103-105; methyl eugenol). IFRA Standards PDF
- IFRA, Guidance for the use of IFRA Standards, 51st Amendment. IFRA Guidance PDF
- PubChem, Eugenol, GHS classification. pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/Eugenol
- OSHA. Hazard Communication Standard: Safety Data Sheets (OSHA 3514). osha.gov