Do You Have to Label Eugenol? Thresholds Explained
Label thresholds for eugenol are tiny. In a 30 g leave-on product, 0.001% is 0.3 mg, a speck you can cross without noticing. If you make perfume, body oil or soap with a spiced fragrance, it is worth knowing when your label has to name eugenol, and when someone else's rules, not yours, decide it.
The sums that matter
The Cosmetics Regulation lists eugenol in Annex III, entry 71, with a labelling condition: it must appear in the ingredient list when its concentration exceeds 0.001% in leave-on products or 0.01% in rinse-off products (legislation.gov.uk, Annex III, the version carried in Great Britain, which ties the rule to Article 19(1)(g)). These are declaration thresholds, not safety limits. For scale, IFRA's fine fragrance limit for eugenol is 2.5% (IFRA Standards, 51st Amendment), 2,500 times the leave-on line.
To find your own trigger, divide the threshold by your fragrance dose. This gives the share of eugenol in the fragrance at which declaration begins.
| Product | Fragrance dose | Threshold | Declare once eugenol is above this share of the fragrance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Leave-on body oil | 1% | 0.001% | 0.1% |
| Fine fragrance | 18% | 0.001% | about 0.0056% |
| Bar soap | 3% | 0.01% | about 0.33% |
The rows are illustrations of the arithmetic, not recipes. A 100 g bar crosses 0.01% at 10 mg of eugenol. And if you add eugenol material directly, even 0.05% of a product is fifty times over the leave-on line, so the declaration is a given rather than a judgment call. To turn a blend into a eugenol percentage, see our blend calculation article. You will need the eugenol content of every fragrance ingredient, which your suppliers can give you.
Why tiny numbers feel strange
A threshold of 0.001% is hard to picture, so it helps to put it on a bench. In a 30 g bottle of body oil it is 0.3 mg, less than the weight of a grain of table salt. You cannot see it, you cannot weigh it on a kitchen scale, and you can still cross it. That is why makers who add any eugenol material on purpose treat the declaration as automatic and do their thinking about the other, smaller sources.
Which products count as cosmetics
Annex III labelling is a cosmetics rule. A perfumed soap, a solid perfume and a body oil are applied to the body, so they fall within it. A candle, wax melt or reed diffuser is not, which means other rules apply, such as hazard labelling for mixtures. How your product is classified where you sell it is a question for a regulatory specialist.
Ask suppliers early
The hardest number to get is usually the eugenol content of the natural ingredients already in your fragrance. Ask each supplier for it in writing, and ask for the safety data sheet and IFRA statement at the same time. A reply that arrives after you have already printed labels is no use to anyone, so we would make this the first step of any new spiced formula and not the last.
What is coming in the United States
Federal law now points toward individual allergen labelling. The Modernization of Cosmetics Regulation Act added section 609(b) to the Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act, which says the responsible person "shall identify on the label of a cosmetic product each fragrance allergen included in such cosmetic product", with the substances to be set by FDA regulation (Public Law 117-328). The statute asks FDA to propose that rule within 18 months of enactment. Since the list is left to FDA, we would watch for it, and it is reasonable to expect the EU numbers to influence it, though that is a prediction.
If you only make soap for friends
Labelling rules matter most when you sell. If a bar is for your own bathroom or a friend's, none of this needs paperwork, but the habit of counting eugenol is still worth building. It teaches you what a spiced fragrance really contains, and it makes the step to selling much easier when you take it. Write the numbers down now, even for a batch nobody will ever ask about.
Keep one page per formula
We would keep a single page for each formula: product name, fragrance dose, every ingredient that contains eugenol with its percentage and the supplier document it came from, the arithmetic, and the date. When a customer, a marketplace or a regulator asks how you decided what goes on the label, you can answer in a minute. When you change a supplier or a recipe, you change the page and redo the sum. It is dull work that pays for itself the first time somebody asks a question.
A short checklist
- Decide whether each product is a cosmetic where you sell it.
- Get the eugenol percentage in your fragrance and compute your trigger.
- List the fragrance as parfum and eugenol separately where the rule applies.
- Re-check the current text and the IFRA category with every new formula; our IFRA explainer and compliance guide help.
This article is not legal advice, and a regulatory specialist should confirm your actual label. Our certificate of analysis lists density, refractive index, appearance and smell for one batch, so if you need an assay for your calculations, ask us in writing through the contact page. Anyone who reacts to a scented product should see a dermatologist or allergist. A little arithmetic up front keeps the label simple later.
Sources & Further Reading
- legislation.gov.uk. Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, Annex III (as carried in Great Britain). legislation.gov.uk/eur/2009/1223/annex/III
- IFRA, 2023. IFRA Standards, 51st Amendment, eugenol. ifra-standards-51st-amendment.pdf
- US Congress, 2022. Public Law 117-328 (MoCRA), section 609 of the FD&C Act. congress.gov PLAW-117publ328